SURRENDER, NEW YORK
BY CALEB CARR | PUBLICATION: AUGUST 23, 2016RANDOM HOUSE | GENRE: MYSTERY & SUSPENSE
RATING: ★★★★★
"Smart, deliberate, and distinctly memorable."
____________________________________________________________________
Caleb Carr, the author of The Alienist and The Angel of Darkness, returns with a contemporary, edge-of-your-seat thriller featuring the brilliant but unconventional criminal psychologist Dr. Trajan Jones.
In the small town of Surrender in upstate New York, Dr. Jones, a psychological profiler, and Dr. Michael Li, a trace evidence expert, teach online courses in profiling and forensic science from Jones’s family farm. Once famed advisors to the New York City Police Department, Trajan and Li now work in exile, having made enemies of those in power. Protected only by farmhands and Jones’s unusual “pet,” the outcast pair is unexpectedly called in to consult on a disturbing case.
In rural Burgoyne County, a pattern of strange deaths has emerged: adolescent boys and girls are found murdered in gruesome fashion. Senior law enforcement officials are quick to blame a serial killer, yet their efforts to apprehend this criminal are peculiarly ineffective.
Jones and Li soon discover that the victims are all “throwaway children,” a new state classification of young people who are neither orphans, runaways, nor homeless, but who are abandoned by their families and left to fend for themselves. Two of these throwaways, Lucas Kurtz and his older sister, Ambyr, cross paths with Jones and Li, offering information that could blow the case wide open.
As the stakes grow higher, Jones and Li must not only unravel the mystery of how the throwaways died but also defend themselves and the Kurtz siblings against shadowy agents who don’t want the truth to get out. Jones believes the real story leads back to the city where both he and Dr. Kreizler did their greatest work. But will Jones and Li be able to trace the case to New York before they fall victim to the murderous forces that stalk them?
Tautly paced and richly researched, Surrender, New York brings to life the grim underbelly of a prosperous nation—and those most vulnerable to its failings. This brilliant novel marks another milestone in Caleb Carr’s triumphant literary suspense career.
In the small town of Surrender in upstate New York, Dr. Jones, a psychological profiler, and Dr. Michael Li, a trace evidence expert, teach online courses in profiling and forensic science from Jones’s family farm. Once famed advisors to the New York City Police Department, Trajan and Li now work in exile, having made enemies of those in power. Protected only by farmhands and Jones’s unusual “pet,” the outcast pair is unexpectedly called in to consult on a disturbing case.
In rural Burgoyne County, a pattern of strange deaths has emerged: adolescent boys and girls are found murdered in gruesome fashion. Senior law enforcement officials are quick to blame a serial killer, yet their efforts to apprehend this criminal are peculiarly ineffective.
Jones and Li soon discover that the victims are all “throwaway children,” a new state classification of young people who are neither orphans, runaways, nor homeless, but who are abandoned by their families and left to fend for themselves. Two of these throwaways, Lucas Kurtz and his older sister, Ambyr, cross paths with Jones and Li, offering information that could blow the case wide open.
As the stakes grow higher, Jones and Li must not only unravel the mystery of how the throwaways died but also defend themselves and the Kurtz siblings against shadowy agents who don’t want the truth to get out. Jones believes the real story leads back to the city where both he and Dr. Kreizler did their greatest work. But will Jones and Li be able to trace the case to New York before they fall victim to the murderous forces that stalk them?
Tautly paced and richly researched, Surrender, New York brings to life the grim underbelly of a prosperous nation—and those most vulnerable to its failings. This brilliant novel marks another milestone in Caleb Carr’s triumphant literary suspense career.
____________________________________________________________________
Ambitious and brave. I expected nothing less from a Caleb Carr novel.
Surrender, New York echoed the spirit of Carr’s Kreizler series, with its 19th-century jargon and meticulous crime investigation techniques. But this novel wasn’t just a nostalgic nod—it was a bold pivot into present-day tragedies, wrapped in Carr’s signature intellectual depth.
Set in the fictional town of Surrender, we meet Trajan Jones, a criminal psychologist, and his partner Michael Li. Exiled from New York City’s academic and law enforcement circles, they now teach criminology online while occasionally consulting for the local sheriff’s office. Their latest case? A disturbing pattern of abandoned children and an unsettling death rate that pits local authorities against larger political forces.
Carr’s signature blend of historical depth and psychological intrigue remains potent. Though the novel’s pacing may challenge readers raised on rapid-fire thrillers, its deliberate unfolding is part of its brilliance. But that slowness is purposeful—it’s where the wisdom lives. The narrative doesn’t lack action or shocking twists, but it earns them through careful buildup and rich context.
What stayed with me most were the characters. Carr doesn’t just write them—he etches them into memory. His characters don’t just populate the story—they haunt it. I still recall how each was introduced, how they reappeared, and how they lingered long after the final page. In crime fiction, connection to the protagonist or antagonist is essential, and Carr’s strategy works damn well.
Surrender, New York echoed the spirit of Carr’s Kreizler series, with its 19th-century jargon and meticulous crime investigation techniques. But this novel wasn’t just a nostalgic nod—it was a bold pivot into present-day tragedies, wrapped in Carr’s signature intellectual depth.
Set in the fictional town of Surrender, we meet Trajan Jones, a criminal psychologist, and his partner Michael Li. Exiled from New York City’s academic and law enforcement circles, they now teach criminology online while occasionally consulting for the local sheriff’s office. Their latest case? A disturbing pattern of abandoned children and an unsettling death rate that pits local authorities against larger political forces.
Carr’s signature blend of historical depth and psychological intrigue remains potent. Though the novel’s pacing may challenge readers raised on rapid-fire thrillers, its deliberate unfolding is part of its brilliance. But that slowness is purposeful—it’s where the wisdom lives. The narrative doesn’t lack action or shocking twists, but it earns them through careful buildup and rich context.
What stayed with me most were the characters. Carr doesn’t just write them—he etches them into memory. His characters don’t just populate the story—they haunt it. I still recall how each was introduced, how they reappeared, and how they lingered long after the final page. In crime fiction, connection to the protagonist or antagonist is essential, and Carr’s strategy works damn well.
Carr doesn’t cater to reader expectations—he reshapes them. He offers something more meaningful than entertainment: a lens through which to examine justice, perception, and truth.
TWITTER | INSTAGRAM | PINTEREST | TUMBLR | BLOGLOVIN | GOODREADS
About the Author:
Caleb Carr is the critically acclaimed author of The Alienist, The Angel of Darkness, The Lessons of Terror, Killing Time, The Devil Soldier, The Italian Secretary, The Legend of Broken, and Surrender, New York. He has taught military history at Bard College, and worked extensively in film, television, and the theater. His military and political writings have appeared in numerous magazines and periodicals, among them The Washington Post, The New York Times, and The Wall Street Journal. He lives in upstate New York.
Photo from PRH. No infringement intended.
*Penguin Random House provided the eARC
in exchange for this unbiased review.
This is a free ad.
in exchange for this unbiased review.
This is a free ad.
Posts
Thank you for such a thoughtful review. I've ordered my copy and look forward to reading it!
ReplyDeleteHope you enjoy it as much as I did. :)
DeleteIt would be really helpful if you posted this review on Goodreads and Amazon as there seem to be many ill-informed readers writing scathing reviews of this book. Some of them don't bother to finish the book. Others, clearly didn't even read it.
ReplyDeleteSorry, I see that you did post on Goodreads. Please disregard my previous comment. Than you.
ReplyDeleteSame sentiments here. I'll try posting this on Amazon as well.
DeleteThank you for dropping by. :)
I agree completely, the novel requires patience but that patience is repaid in manifold ways by Mr. Carr. The characters are engaging, if a bit eccentric, he intelligently discourses on criminal justice issues without becoming pedantic, and most importantly for a mystery novel, he makes the reader eager to follow in the steps of his two detectives to find the truth. Bravo, Mr Carr, for the courage to take the time and the thought to write a novel that stays with the reader. And for what it is worth, I am a former prosecutor, and a current criminal court judge, and this writer knows what he is talking about.
DeleteThank you for sharing, Peter!
Delete